WASHINGTON (AP) - President Donald Trump's campaign is pushing a familiar line of attack: unverified allegations about Biden's son and his foreign business ties. However, reporting in the New York Post, and the emergence of a man who says he worked with Hunter Biden, have raised more questions than answers, including about the authenticity of emails at the center of the story.
The origins of renewed allegations trace back to Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani, who has pushed claims about the Bidens. Even if the emails in the Post are legitimate, they don't validate Trump and Giuliani's claims that Biden's actions were influenced by his son's business dealings.
HOW DID BIDEN'S SON BECOME A CAMPAIGN ISSUE?
Hunter Biden joined the board of the Ukrainian gas company Burisma in 2014, around the time his father, then U.S. vice president, was helping conduct the Obama administration's foreign policy with Ukraine.
Senate Republicans said in a recent report the appointment may have posed a conflict of interest, but they did not present evidence that the hiring influenced U.S. policies.
Trump and his supporters, meanwhile, have advanced a widely discredited theory that Biden pushed for the firing of Ukraine's top prosecutor to protect his son and Burisma from investigation. Biden did indeed press for the prosecutor's firing because he was reflecting the official position of not only the Obama administration but many Western countries and because the prosecutor was perceived as soft on corruption.
WHAT DOES THE NEW YORK POST SAY?
The main email highlighted by the Post is an April 2015 message that it said was sent to Hunter Biden by Vadym Pozharskyi, an adviser to Burisma's board. In it, he thanks the younger Biden "for inviting me to DC and giving an opportunity to meet your father and spent (sic) some time together. It's realty (sic) an honor and pleasure."
The wording makes it unclear if he actually met Joe Biden. The Biden campaign said in a statement that it had reviewed Biden's schedules from the time, and no meeting as described by the newspaper took place.
HOW DID THE POST OBTAIN THE EMAILS?
The Post said it received a copy of a hard drive containing the messages from Giuliani, who has pushed the idea Ukraine was trying to interfere with the 2016 election and the younger Biden may have enriched himself by selling his access to his father.
The Post said the emails were part of a trove of data recovered from a laptop dropped off in April 2019 at a computer repair shop in Delaware. It said the customer, whom the owner could not definitively identify as Hunter Biden, never paid for the service or retrieved it and said the owner made a copy of the hard drive he provided to Giuliani's lawyer.
The owner of the Wilmington shop declined to comment to the Associated Press, but in news media interviews he has said he contacted the FBI through an intermediary and provided agents with a copy of the hard drive's contents.
ARE THE NEW EMAILS AUTHENTIC?
Hunter Biden himself has not spoken publicly in recent weeks, including to confirm whether or not the laptop is his. The Biden campaign has also not addressed that question, though a lawyer for Hunter Biden, George Mesires, said in a statement "we have no idea where this came from, and certainly cannot credit anything that Rudy Giuliani provided to the NY Post."
Some former national security officials and other experts said the episode raised multiple red flags of a possible Russian disinformation effort, especially given the involvement of Giuliani and his active role in promoting an anti-Biden narrative on Ukraine.
However, John Ratcliffe, the director of national intelligence, knocked down that idea, saying, "The intelligence community doesn't believe that because there's no intelligence that supports that."
The FBI appeared to endorse Ratcliffe's position in a letter to a Senate committee that had requested information on the laptop.
"Regarding the subject of your letter, we have nothing to add at this time to the October 19th public statement by the Director of National Intelligence about the available actionable intelligence," wrote Jill Tyson, director of the office of Congressional Affairs, in the letter to Sen. Ron Johnson, the Republican chairman of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
Tyson also said she could not confirm or deny the existence of any investigation, in keeping with Justice Department practice.
IF AUTHENTIC, ARE THESE EMAILS DAMAGING TO BIDEN?
The suggestion that Joe Biden might have met with a Burisma representative is consequential, because he has repeatedly insisted he never discussed his son's business with him.
However, the emails provide no details on whether Pozharskyi and Biden actually met and, if so, what they discussed.
If Biden did meet with Pozharskyi, he was not the only U.S. official who may have done so. Pozharskyi was part of a Burisma delegation that lobbied congressional officials in 2014 in an attempt to show the firm was not a corruption risk.
WHAT'S THE POLITICAL IMPACT?
With Election Day near and polls showing him trailing Biden, Trump appears to be returning to the subject of his opponent's family to energize his base.
However, in an election dominated by concerns about the coronavirus pandemic, it's less certain Trump's strategy will appeal to the voters he needs to win back, including moderate Republicans and suburban women.
Trump sprinkled allegations against Biden and his son in the second and last presidential debate. Ahead of the debate, the Trump campaign also organized a press event featuring Tony Bobulinski, a man who said he was Hunter Biden's former business partner. Bobulinski made unproven allegations that the vice president's son consulted with his father on China-related business dealings.
The Associated Press could not independently verify Bobulinski's allegations.
Biden's campaign, meanwhile, pointed to the recent Republican-led Senate investigation that found no evidence of wrongdoing on Biden's part with regard to Ukraine. It also pointedly noted the involvement of Giuliani, saying his "discredited conspiracy theories and alliance with figures connected to Russian intelligence have been widely reported."